The culture in Singapore has been described as a mix between Chinese, Indian, Malay and British culture, which serves as a reflection of our immigration history. However, there can be problems in communication between a Singaporean Chinese and a native Chinese (i.e. immigrants from China).
I am in the midst of preparing for the NUS Chinese Dance production which will be held in 9 days time. This scenario that I will be describing just happened hours ago during our full dress rehearsal. Our multimedia designer is a Singaporean Chinese, who though is a Chinese does not speak Mandarin at all. On the other hand, our resident choreographer is a native Chinese, who does not speak English. So the first problem of communication is the language. This was easily solved as all of the crew present are able to speak both English and Mandarin and could help in the interpretation.
The real problem comes when they got to the concept of propriety in the Pre-Han era. There is one dance item in our production entitled 《礼记》or Books of Rites, which talks about ettiquette being the embodiment of morality while morality forms the basis of ettiquette. Our resident choreographer wanted to depict this concept using education based on Confucius and Lao Tze. However, the multimedia designer interpreted it as scholars obtaining honours in the imperial exams by working hard, having neat handwriting (at that time, the neatness of one's handwriting shows how hard-working you are) and by becoming an officer. As a result, both parties had to sit down with some of the crew to make sure that both parties have communicated effectively.
Reflecting on it now, the difference in value systems of both the individuals played a huge role in the initial interpretation of the concept of propriety in my opinion. For our resident choreographer, her interpretation was largely based on the thought that education is the most important factor in nurturing one to have moral values that are acceptable by the society such as respectfulness. However, the multimedia designer's interpretation was based on the concept that success is more important as the "accepted standards" of behaviours and morals are largely linked to success nowadays. What was lacking in this interaction was understanding of the value systems of the other individual, which in my opinion is shaped from the environment that one grew up in, which is their culture.
Through this, I find it interesting that even two people of the same roots can have a different set of value systems, and also they can speak a different language that the other cannot understand.
5 comments:
Hi Hannah,
I thought that your intercultural scenario was pretty interesting. I can totally comprehend why the multimedia designer would deem the idea of success as the norm standard in Singapore’s context. We have been brought up with the notion that education is vital for survival in Singapore, and without a decent paper qualification, you will not be successful in life. The education system in Singapore has been steering us towards good education qualifications, excellent grades and everything related to the academic arena. This has impacted us Singaporeans to hold on to that belief that education and success are inseparable and is essential in our society today. We live in this competitive society where only the best gets the job, only the most capable one gets to climb the social ladder. Thus, it is not surprising that the multimedia designer, who is a Singaporean, regards the idea of success to be the most acceptable standard. The importance of family values is slowly diminishing and being replaced with a career oriented mind-set. Our values and beliefs are shaped by the culture that we are brought up in and therefore, I am able to see the perspective of the multimedia designer.
Sharlene.
Hi Sharlene
I do share your views to. In today's society I do think that most of what we do is to acheive some form of success in the future, be it a higher social status or in the form of monetary gains. Maybe this is why the birth-rate in Singapore is rapidly declining, as family has taken a back seat in the society.
Regards
Hannah
Hi Hannah,
I guess it's a general consensus that one is considered successful if he/she is at a higher career or social status. To most of us, monetary gains is our top priority because of the high living standard in Singapore . We did not have a choice cause if everyone is moving on rapidly and you are still at the same spot, you will be at the losing end. This is why nowadays parents are sending their kids to enrichment classes at a very early age. They hope that their kids will have a good head start above others.
We are constantly rushing to be at the front and gradually missing out the little things in life. Things like kinship, friendship and relationship. The definition of happiness in our society have indeed changed to becoming more materialistic.
Michelle
Like the other readers note, this is an interesting scenario, one that well illustrates how cultural background is more compelling when it comes to putting values into practice than having shared cultural heritage.
My only question is about the notion of depicting "this concept." Do you mean to say that there was a scene where such a depiction was a matter of interpretation in the form of theatrical moves? This could have been made clearer by a sentence of explanation.
In any case, I really appreciate your effort and the sharing of this example.
Hi Prof Blackstone
I do not understand what did you mean by the notion of depicting the concept. Does it refer to the sentence "Our resident choreographer wanted to depict this concept using education based on Confucius and Lao Tze".
If so, I meant that because we are also incorporating multimedia projections into the dance, our resident choreographer wanted to paint a clear picture with pictures and sayings (in the calligraphy form) of Confucius and Lao Tze.
I hope this is clearer now.
Regards
Hannah
Post a Comment